Forced to have a Covid-19 vaccination by your employer?
What are your employment rights when it comes to mandatory vaccination policies?
On 11 November 2021 the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) (Amendment) (Coronavirus) Regulations 2021 (‘the regulations’) came into force. This follows months of consultations and guidance from the UK Government in their attempt to transition the care sector into this new model.
Mandatory vaccination within the care sector
It will become a legal requirement for those within the care sector, and third-party sectors that operate within this structure, to have all staff and volunteers vaccinated for them to carry out their role. The regulations mean that all registered Care Quality Commission (CQC) registered care homes (which provide accommodation together with nursing or personal care) must ensure that a person does not enter the indoor premises unless they have been vaccinated. This is subject to certain exemptions.
Businesses operating outside of the care sector
Guidance for those that operate within the care sector is clear, but many employers from different industries are now asking what they can be doing to protect their employees and service users in the continued fight against Covid? It is clear, however, that currently these regulations do not extend to other industries or sectors. That means that currently employers outside the care sector can certainly encourage their staff to receive the vaccine, but vaccinations remain voluntary.
Can an employer enforce a mandatory vaccination programme?
A recent survey commissioned by Indeed Flex found that 70% of HR directors were planning to implement vaccine mandates in the workplace, with 22% requiring vaccinations to be required even where employees can evidence potential exemptions.
An employer who is not mandated by the
regulations and requires employees to receive a vaccination could potentially
be open to the risk of a discrimination claim on the grounds of disability,
age, religion or belief. In addition, if an employer were to dismiss an
employee for the reason of refusing to take a vaccine, they may be opening
themselves up to an unfair dismissal claim.
ACAS have recently released guidance that supports employers encouraging discussions with employees regarding vaccination status within the workplace. In summary, the guidance advises employers of ways to have discussions with employees about being vaccinated, recommending employers to include recognised trade union or staff representatives in any discussions.
It is not currently prohibited for employers to introduce vaccination policies, but it is advised that employers discuss any plans to implement policies on vaccination with a professional legal advisor, to ensure that they are balanced and fair, having in mind their employee’s human rights, ethical concerns and potential for discriminative practice.
Mandatory vs voluntary
The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) has set out guidance for employers that clarifies that vaccination policies should consider the legal aspects with respect to discrimination claims, as well as providing information on data protection and health and safety duties. A policy can potentially be objectively justified as a means of achieving the legitimate aim of staff health and safety. Vaccination policies may be a balanced way of achieving those aims, although this will depend upon the way in which they are operated and the impact on the individual employee.
A vaccination policy can be part of the overall Covid-19 secure steps towards maximising the number of employees who can attend work safely. However, it is only part of the overall solution and not a substitute for other measures.
Organisations that are not mandated by the regulations should follow a voluntary approach when setting out its aims and objectives in a policy. As well as the legal and financial risks of adopting a mandatory approach, engaging employees with a voluntary approach will build trust and encourage employees to appreciate the benefits for themselves and others. The policy can help explain the benefits of vaccination and how employees can contribute to wider public health by protecting themselves and other employees and the wider community by being vaccinated.
NHS vaccine mandate
Since the introduction of the regulations, it has been announced by the government that the requirement to be vaccinated will extend to NHS frontline staff and those within the social care sector. This will be applicable to doctors, nurses, dentists, domiciliary care workers, volunteers and ancillary staff like porters and receptionists who may have contact with patients but are not involved directly in their care. This will come into effect by 1 April 2022 and at this point it will be expected that these members of staff should already be double vaccinated. It appears that only those who do not have face-to-face contact with patients or who are medically exempt will not be required to get vaccinated.
If you are an employee and are unsure of your rights in terms of your employer’s vaccination policy or the mandatory vaccination regulations that affect your role, you should seek professional legal advice from a solicitor who will be able to advise based upon your personal circumstances.
If you are an employer and would like to speak to a legal advisor to discuss the drafting, implementation or potential for, a vaccination policy to be implemented within your company we would encourage you to liaise with an employment law team.
You can search for a solicitor who specialises in employment law for free on our website, and without having to provide your personal data. Our site has lots of guidance on how to find the right lawyer for you and how to pay for their services. Sometimes you may not have to find the money yourself and our site guidance explains why, read our guidance on how to pay your legal fees.